What I LIKED :
1. It's Vidya Balan all the way. A couple of weeks ago, Ranbir stamped his authority to bag the Best Actor awards next year. This Friday seals it for the Best Actress one. The ease with which she slips into the character, will shock the ones, who were spell-bound by her roles/performances in Parineeta and Paa.
2. Silk's character is unapologetic about herself, right from start to end . She is flawed, outrageously bold with negative shades and hence the character is believable. This morning, I read some reports comparing the central plot with Madhur Bhandarkar's Fashion, which's uncalled for, as Priyanka's character is much more vulnerable then Vidya's.
3. Some scenes were superbly handled. Like the one in which Vidya kisses Tushar to spoil '2 parties', the one in which Vidya runs around the street crazily shouting if anyone's there to talk, the award speech by vidya...
3. Emraan Hashmi's character graphing was interesting. After making all the bold statements to prove movies primarily run cause of scripts, eventually even he falls prey to the commercial masala towards the end.
4. The bold scenes are so erotic, but they are never obscene or vulgar. That's a difficult thing to achieve.
What I DIDN'T LIKE :
1. Vidya-Emran conversations.
As Abraham (Emran's character) can't stand the fact that item songs and masala sell, and not award-winning scripts, his scenes with Vidya should have lightened up the screen. Instead what we have, is the cliched 'i win, you lose' stuff. Abraham developing feelings for Silk, out of nowhere, is also hard to digest.
2. Suddenly, Vidya and her rival star break into a dance at a party.
3. The completely misplaced sufiyana song, pushed in, probably in the most boring 15 minutes of the movie.
4. Fine, dialogues are great but why throw in heavy-weight lines at every possible chance ?? They consistently range from being cheesy (dil hota hai left mein, magar hamesha right hota hai) to applause worthy (har aadmi ke liye ek aurat bani hai... jab tak usse bachoge, aage badhoge) that after a point, you feel every character in the movie is a born poet and writer.
What I HATED :
TUSHAR KAPOOR .... Any tom,dick, harry could have played that role. Why him ? .. just look at the way he looks at Vidya .. like a 5 year old kid, desperately expecting a chocolate from Silk aunty ..
Verdict :
Its not perfect, not even close . Its a just-about-good movie, made enjoyable by the livewire act of Vidya Balan. Watch it once !
My Rating : 3/5
1. It's Vidya Balan all the way. A couple of weeks ago, Ranbir stamped his authority to bag the Best Actor awards next year. This Friday seals it for the Best Actress one. The ease with which she slips into the character, will shock the ones, who were spell-bound by her roles/performances in Parineeta and Paa.
2. Silk's character is unapologetic about herself, right from start to end . She is flawed, outrageously bold with negative shades and hence the character is believable. This morning, I read some reports comparing the central plot with Madhur Bhandarkar's Fashion, which's uncalled for, as Priyanka's character is much more vulnerable then Vidya's.
3. Some scenes were superbly handled. Like the one in which Vidya kisses Tushar to spoil '2 parties', the one in which Vidya runs around the street crazily shouting if anyone's there to talk, the award speech by vidya...
3. Emraan Hashmi's character graphing was interesting. After making all the bold statements to prove movies primarily run cause of scripts, eventually even he falls prey to the commercial masala towards the end.
4. The bold scenes are so erotic, but they are never obscene or vulgar. That's a difficult thing to achieve.
What I DIDN'T LIKE :
1. Vidya-Emran conversations.
As Abraham (Emran's character) can't stand the fact that item songs and masala sell, and not award-winning scripts, his scenes with Vidya should have lightened up the screen. Instead what we have, is the cliched 'i win, you lose' stuff. Abraham developing feelings for Silk, out of nowhere, is also hard to digest.
2. Suddenly, Vidya and her rival star break into a dance at a party.
3. The completely misplaced sufiyana song, pushed in, probably in the most boring 15 minutes of the movie.
4. Fine, dialogues are great but why throw in heavy-weight lines at every possible chance ?? They consistently range from being cheesy (dil hota hai left mein, magar hamesha right hota hai) to applause worthy (har aadmi ke liye ek aurat bani hai... jab tak usse bachoge, aage badhoge) that after a point, you feel every character in the movie is a born poet and writer.
What I HATED :
TUSHAR KAPOOR .... Any tom,dick, harry could have played that role. Why him ? .. just look at the way he looks at Vidya .. like a 5 year old kid, desperately expecting a chocolate from Silk aunty ..
Verdict :
Its not perfect, not even close . Its a just-about-good movie, made enjoyable by the livewire act of Vidya Balan. Watch it once !
My Rating : 3/5